Searching over 5,500,000 cases.


searching
Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.

City of Charlottesville v. Sclafani

Court of Appeals of Virginia

July 23, 2019

CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE
v.
WILLIAM SCLAFANI

          FROM THE VIRGINIA WORKERS' COMPENSATION COMMISSION

          Brian J. McNamara (Brian A. Richardson; Faraaz A. Jindani; Ford Richardson, PC, on briefs), for appellant.

          Bradford M. Young (HammondTownsend, PLC, on brief), for appellee.

          Present: Judges Chafin, Russell and Senior Judge Clements Argued at Salem, Virginia

          OPINION

          TERESA M. CHAFIN, JUDGE

         William Sclafani, a Charlottesville police officer, injured his left arm and shoulder while playing the role of a restrained suspect during a SWAT team training activity. The City of Charlottesville ("the City") now appeals the decision of the Virginia Workers' Compensation Commission awarding Sclafani temporary total disability from July 21, 2017, through August 15, 2017 in addition to medical benefits. On appeal, the City argues that the Commission erred in finding that Sclafani suffered a compensable, discrete injury by accident arising out of employment.[1] For the reasons that follow, we reverse the Commission's finding and remand for further fact finding.

         Background

         "On appeal from a decision of the . . . Commission, the evidence and all reasonable inferences that may be drawn from that evidence are viewed in the light most favorable to the prevailing party below," in this case, Sclafani. Anderson v. Anderson, 65 Va.App. 354, 361 (2015) (quoting Artis v. Ottenberg's Bakers, Inc., 45 Va.App. 72, 83 (2005)). So viewed, the facts are as follows.

         On May 9, 2017, Sclafani played the role of a suspect who needed to be restrained for a SWAT team training activity. The training lasted from approximately 8:00 a.m. until between 4:30 and 5:00 p.m. In his role as a suspect, Sclafani was repeatedly handcuffed, thrown to and picked up off the ground while in handcuffs. Sclafani testified that while he did feel some mild discomfort throughout the day, he denied feeling a "pop" or sudden acute pain. In fact, he stated in his deposition testimony that he advised his doctors that there was no immediate onset of significant pain. However, as he was leaving the training, Sclafani noticed that he could not straighten his left arm on the steering wheel. Later that evening, he could not raise his left arm straight up or down. Sclafani testified that the pain did not really begin until the following day.

         While Sclafani reported his injury to his sergeant, he did not seek treatment with Kristine Shannon, a nurse practitioner, until May 12, 2017. Shannon advised him to see a specialist if he did not improve within three weeks. Sclafani ultimately sought treatment from Dr. William T. Grant, an orthopedist, who gave him a steroid injection and referred him to physical therapy. Sclafani underwent surgery on his left shoulder on July 26, 2017. On August 10, 2017, the orthopedist opined that Sclafani could resume light-duty work on August 16, 2017. Sclafani's light-duty status was continued on September 7, 2017. On September 28, 2017, Sclafani was released to recommence full duty work.

         Sclafani filed a claim alleging injury by accident to his left shoulder and arm and seeking an award of medical benefits and temporary total disability benefits from July 21, 2017, to August 16, 2017. The City asserted that Sclafani did not suffer a compensable, discrete injury by accident. The City further alleged that the medical evidence did not support the period of disability alleged by Sclafani.

         Following a hearing, the deputy commissioner issued an opinion on July 20, 2018, finding that Sclafani failed to prove his arm and shoulder injury was compensable. The deputy commissioner further explained that although Sclafani did have a clearly defined injury, there was no acute onset of pain. To be compensable, the deputy commissioner concluded that the Commission would have to broaden the definition of "rigid temporal precision" to include injuries that occurred at an unidentified point during an eight-hour period. Because Sclafani was unable to identify a certain point during the eight-hour training at which his injury occurred, the deputy commissioner denied Sclafani's claim for benefits.

         Sclafani appealed to the full Commission. The full Commission reversed the deputy commissioner's denial of Sclafani's claim. Based on the factual similarities between the two cases, the Commission relied in large part on its own decision in Bandy v. Department of Motor Vehicles, JCN VA00001370700 (Va. Wrk. Comp. Nov. 2, 2018), in reversing the deputy commissioner's decision. The Commission found that Sclafani's case was similar to Bandy in that "the eight-hour training session . . . provided the necessary rigidity of temporal precision to constitute one ...


Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.